Originally published on The Wine Gang‘s website.
We wine nerds (see below) all seek Pinot perfection in our own idiosyncratic way, even when it comes to Burgundy we split hairs between villages and vineyards to satisfy our personal Pinot particulars.
Speaking of which Burgundy is where my whole wine journey began, so if anyone had said to me – before my trip to California two weeks ago – that I’d have a Pinot epiphany in California, I’m reasonably confident I would have laughed in their face.
Well, can someone hand me a large slice of humble pie right now please because it happened, I had the The Perfect Pinot Moment. Y’know, the kind of one that goes beyond appreciating the quality of it and just tugs at the heartstrings because it was so mind-blowingly delicious?
I swear the MW standing next to me shed a tear as she tasted it.
This all took place in California’s cooler spot of Sonoma but the wine responsible for all the high emotion actually came from Santa Cruz Mountains, one of California’s very first demarcated wine regions (called American Viticultural Areas, or AVAs).
More specifically, the wine was made by Arnot-Roberts, a modest and thoughtful producer that I requested to visit on this trip thanks to a tip-off from Mick Craven at Craven Wines, an Australian winemaker now based in Stellenbosch but who has spent some time on the West Coast.
Duncan Arnot and Nathan Roberts have known each other since third grade but took slightly different wine paths at first; Duncan as a winemaker and Nathan – brilliantly – as a trained cooper, until they collaborated to make their first vintage in 2002.
The guys have benefited from land and grapes that other people have discarded in California “because they couldn’t producer the powerhouse wines that people wanted.” Well those are exactly the kind of vineyards that Duncan and Nathan didwant, because it plays to their desire to make delicate wines.
And delicate they are. In fact the whole Arnot-Roberts tasting was a lesson in authenticity, delicacy and freshness. Everything from their Trousseau Noir to their Syrah had character and drinkability. The Peter Martin Ray Vineyard Pinot Noir 2014 (above) especially, which comes from one of the oldest plantings of Pinot Noir in North America. It was replanted in 1979. It was fresh, creamy, slightly toasty, juicy, crunchy, salty, lightly spicy and had a sublime texture. Rich but elegant. I just couldn’t leave without buying a bottle, and I wasn’t the only one.
That was one special highlight from the week on the West Coast, but it was an epic week all in. Our road trip (group picture at the top) covered Santa Barbara, Paso Robles and Napa, but it was in Sonoma where that long-reported-on rhetoric came to life, Californian wine really does have SO much going on.
Duncan Arnot and Nathan Roberts have known each other since third grade but took slightly different wine paths at first; Duncan as a winemaker and Nathan – brilliantly – as a trained cooper, until they collaborated to make their first vintage in 2002.
The guys have benefited from land and grapes that other people have discarded in California “because they couldn’t producer the powerhouse wines that people wanted.” Well those are exactly the kind of vineyards that Duncan and Nathan didwant, because it plays to their desire to make delicate wines.
And delicate they are. In fact the whole Arnot-Roberts tasting was a lesson in authenticity, delicacy and freshness. Everything from their Trousseau Noir to their Syrah had character and drinkability. The Peter Martin Ray Vineyard Pinot Noir 2014 (above) especially, which comes from one of the oldest plantings of Pinot Noir in North America. It was replanted in 1979. It was fresh, creamy, slightly toasty, juicy, crunchy, salty, lightly spicy and had a sublime texture. Rich but elegant. I just couldn’t leave without buying a bottle, and I wasn’t the only one.
That was one special highlight from the week on the West Coast, but it was an epic week all in. Our road trip (group picture at the top) covered Santa Barbara, Paso Robles and Napa, but it was in Sonoma where that long-reported-on rhetoric came to life, Californian wine really does have SO much going on.